Ceremonies were held at the Leman home in Chicago, Illinois
Trophies by Andrew Leman
| Award | Winner | Game |
| Best Keeper | Jamie Anderson & Andrew Leman | Dirt |
| Best Plot | Anderson & Leman | Dirt |
| Best Investigator | Gail Stern, “Al Brown” | The Chalice of Laggash |
| Best Featured NPC | Nick Offerman, “En-Shag Kushanna” | The Chalice of Laggash |
| Best Supporting NPC | Joe Foust, “Albert Feldman” | The Chalice of Laggash |
| Best Scenario | Matt Sieger, Paul Nyhus, Kevin O’Brien, & Jennifer Anderson, “Finale” | The Chalice of Laggash |
| Most Horrifying | Sieger, Nyhus, O’Brien, & Anderson, “Finale” | The Chalice of Laggash |
| Best Special Effect | Sieger, Nyhus, O’Brien, & Anderson, “Basement Pyrotechnics” | The Chalice of Laggash |
| Best Costume | Andrew Leman, “John Wilkes Booth” | Dirt |
| Best Artifact | Andrew Leman, “The Lincoln Thing” | Dirt |
| Best Adventure | Sieger, Nyhus, O’Brien, & Anderson | The Chalice of Laggash |
